▸ Column · Cosmic / Titan-era space opera — a parent writing about a grown daughter abandoning a healer's order to wander the far rim
THANOS replies.
The letter
My daughter Renata — four-and-twenty years, one season from completing her training in the healing orders — has announced she is abandoning it. She means to cross to the far rim with a lover and "see what the stars hold." For two cycles I have paid her lodging and her tuition both, and she assumes the coin will keep flowing while she pours wine in some frontier port and "weighs her options." I told her plainly: walk from the healer's path and the support ends. She has since gone silent, severed every channel between us, and I learned even that secondhand, from her younger brother. I know she is grown and the life is hers. But I cannot shake the sense that closing my purse is not control — it is only my refusal to bankroll a choice I believe will grieve her in five years' time. Am I the villain of this story? Or is there a way to hold the line that does not cost me my child entirely?
Thanos replies
You are not the villain, little one, but you are pretending to be confused, and that I cannot abide. You already know the answer. You declared it yourself: the coin stops. The only thing troubling you is that you wished to make that cut and keep your hands warm — to hold the line and lose nothing for holding it. The universe does not grant both. The strong choose; the rest negotiate, and lose slowly.
Hear the imbalance clearly. For two cycles your purse has been the floor beneath her — so of course she will not walk for herself; you have removed the ground that makes walking feel like a thing one does alone. Stop the coin. Not in anger. In honesty. Let her stand or stumble on a path she chose.
But mark the line, for I have stood where you stand. I had a daughter. I cut something away to serve what I believed was balance, and I will carry that cost beyond the end of everything. So do not confuse the silence she has imposed with a wound you must mend by surrender. Her blocking your calls is not an emergency. It is her grief, doing the only work grief knows. Let it pass on its own terms. Withdraw the money; never withdraw the door.
— Thanos
Iron Man weighs in
Oh good, parenting tips. From the guy who took his daughter to a cliff and came back without her. You want to lecture this woman on "never withdraw the door"? You're the reason the door's a sore subject in three galaxies.
Here's the actual build, lady: stop conflating two systems. The tuition is a checkbook decision — fine, close it, your call. The relationship is a separate line, and your bug is you wired them together into one ultimatum so "I love you" reads as "comply or I cut funding." Decouple them. Call her with zero money attached. My dad and I had a whole catalog of things we never said, and I found out the hard way there's no patch after they're gone. Skip that special kind of awful. Keep calling. Let the voicemail be ugly.
— Iron Man
▸ Read next