▸ Column · Modern Gotham syndicate era — the Penguin holding court at the Iceberg Lounge, reading correspondence between deals
THE PENGUIN replies.
Replied to by The Penguin, with a rebuttal from Batman.
The letter
My associate Priya and I came up together — ten years of shared tables and shared troubles. Over time I've fronted her the small things: tickets, a dinner for her fellow, a streaming account she's repaid exactly once, back in the spring of '24. She's into me for something north of three hundred now. Every reminder earns the same "oh, I forgot, tonight for certain" — and then nothing. Last week she asked me to cover her share of a getaway deposit, another hundred and seventy-five, on the promise of a check that's "coming." The sum won't break me. The pattern is what stings: I've begun to feel less like her friend and more like her bank. Am I a doormat if I pay again, or a heel if I finally say no? How do I raise this without detonating a decade of friendship over a few transfers?
The Penguin replies
My dear correspondent, you have made the amateur's error: you keep calling it a friendship when the ledger clearly calls it a line of credit. Three hundred and forty dollars, unsecured, no collateral, no interest — why, I've seen Falcone's people draw blood over less, and with far less paperwork than you've politely declined to keep.
Understand the bird you're feeding. Priya hasn't forgotten a penny. She has simply discovered that the umbrella never closes — that the rain never reaches her so long as you're standing there holding it. That is not affection, that is accounting, and she is the only one in your little arrangement who's been doing the math.
So. The deposit? You decline — graciously, with a smile that could chill the Iceberg Lounge. Then you do what no doormat ever does: you remember. Out loud. Pleasantly. "Of course, darling — shall we settle the three-forty first?" Make the debt a thing that travels with her name into every room. A gentleman never forgives a balance; he collects it, and turns a careless debtor into a person who owes him a favor far more valuable than cash. Waugh-waugh! Land on top, old bird.
— The Penguin
Batman weighs in
Cobblepot turns a friend into an asset. Predictable. Wrong.
She isn't a debt to leverage. She's already shown you who she is. Two years. One repayment. That's not forgetfulness. That's a decision.
Don't scheme. Don't collect. Don't hold the three-forty over her like the Penguin holds a marker. That keeps her in your life as a transaction. You don't want her there.
Say no to the deposit. Once. No speech. Then watch what she does unprompted. People reveal themselves when the cushion disappears.
If the friendship can't survive the word "no," it was never the thing you're grieving. Stop financing the lie.
— Batman
▸ Read next