▸ Column · Contemporary boardroom Metropolis — an advice column landing on the desk of LexCorp's chairman.
LEX LUTHOR replies.
Replied to by Lex Luthor, with a rebuttal from Splinter.
The letter
My husband's sister, Renata, has now confirmed and then vanished from six gatherings running — our daughter's birthday brunch, two dinners, a lake-house weekend, and, the last straw, my husband's retirement party. She RSVPs days ahead, then texts a "headache" or a "something came up" about two hours before start time. It isn't only the sting: I cater to a headcount, and her ghosting has cost me real money twice. When I raised it gently at Thanksgiving she went wounded, said she'd "never actually promised," and my mother-in-law took her side and called me "rigid about parties." I genuinely enjoy Renata on the rare day she appears. But I can't keep laying a place for someone who treats an invitation as a mood rather than a commitment. Is there a graceful way to repair this — or to quietly stop inviting her — without blowing up the whole family?
Lex Luthor replies
Oh, sweetheart. No. Renata isn't flaky — she's a sophisticated buyer who's discovered your event has no cancellation policy. She gets the warmth of being wanted plus the freedom of never arriving, and you absorb the catering and the reputational hit. (Your mother-in-law, meanwhile, gets to referee and keep you cast as the rigid one. Three people are enjoying this. You are not one of them.)
So stop trying to "fix the dynamic." There's nothing broken, darling — the system performs beautifully for the two people who built it.
One move, this week. The next invitation reads: "So glad — plates run sixty this round; I'll add you the moment your share clears, fully refundable if you cancel by noon two days out." She will be insulted. The insult is your answer. A guest who means to come wires a refundable deposit without blinking; a guest who was never coming suddenly remembers her headache.
I throw a foundation gala every spring. The ones who confirm and evaporate are never the busy people — they're the ones who crave the asking and dread the being seen. I stopped seating them. The tables filled anyway. Frankly, so will yours.
— Lex Luthor
Splinter weighs in
My child, Luthor reads a ledger where I read a frightened person. A woman who confirms with real hope, then flees two hours before the door — that is not a thief pricing your patience. That is someone whose dread arrives on schedule. Send her the invoice and you will learn only what an invoice teaches: nothing.
Stop laying her place, yes — that is honesty, not cruelty. But go to her once, not about catering. Ask what the headache is guarding. Anger is grief that has not found its words; so, often, is the empty chair. You may be the only one who ever asks.
— Splinter
▸ Read next