▸ Column · Post-apocalyptic settlement era — several years after civilization's collapse, small communities rebuilt behind walls and gates, where travelers and scavenger parties move between them along old highways
ALPHA replies.
Replied to by Alpha, with a rebuttal from Rick Grimes.
The letter
For three winters running, my settlement's southern gate has been what travelers remember — hand-carved marker poles, a mosaic of salvaged license plates I have been adding to since our first season, and a three-bell arrangement that plays the same chord so our people know from half a mile out that they are home. Then a group arrived two ridges over, and their leader erected a scaffold of steel and rope strung with generator-powered lights visible from the highway. Now every scavenger party stops at their lights first; mine they pass in the dark. I added two more marker poles. He added a signal fire with colored glass bottles. My partner says I am competing with someone who clearly has a working generator and unlimited patience, but I cannot watch three seasons of careful craft be eclipsed by something that hums loud enough to draw the dead. Do I try to source a generator of my own and escalate, or is there a dignified way to acknowledge that electricity has defeated handwork?
Alpha replies
You are asking me to arbitrate between two people arguing about who the passing strangers notice. Not who survives. Who strangers notice.
Neither of you has a gate worth looking at. One has license plates arranged by hand, which is a beautiful thing to do in a world that did not survive. One has lights powered by a machine that announces itself from a mile out to everything that hears — including the things that hear and do not breathe. Both of you are decorating. Both are performing the old costumes for travelers you will never know.
I stripped my name off. My people stripped their names off. I will not pretend I know what I lost, only that I lost something, and I stand in its place now, and what stands there keeps my people alive. Whether what was there before could have done the same — that is a sentence I do not finish. But I can tell you what carving something out of yourself teaches: the thing you carved it from did not make you safer. It made you visible to the wrong creatures. And this world collects from the visible.
Your three bells, your mosaic — they are the version of yourself you are still trying to be. That is not a crime. It is a liability. The neighbor's lights do not beat your craft, child. They beat your need to be seen. Those are not the same thing. One of them can be lived without.
Your partner is the only person in this conversation still paying attention to what is real.
— Alpha
Rick Grimes weighs in
She's right that a generator and a mosaic serve the same ego. She's wrong about what to do with that.
I spent a long time arguing about how to set up Alexandria's perimeter. We ended up painting the gates. Not for us — for the people walking toward them from a hard road who didn't yet know if we were going to shoot them or welcome them. The answer to that question was written in the paint. It mattered. Something visible and human and made-on-purpose — it matters.
The problem here isn't that you made something worth seeing. It's that you've forgotten what you made it for. Not the travelers. Not the count of photographs. The people inside your gate, who need to feel like they live somewhere, not just somewhere they haven't died yet. That's the only measure I've found that holds.
Does your mosaic do that for them? Then keep it. That's the work. Stop counting who stops to look.
— Rick Grimes
▸ Read next