▸ Column · Contemporary mutant-rights era — the world of homo superior, where the visibly different move through conferences and hotel lobbies alongside the people who once tormented them as children.
MAGNETO replies.
Replied to by Magneto, with a rebuttal from Professor X.
The letter
I'm thirty-four, and I still can't eat in a crowded room without checking every face first. In middle school a pack of boys used to photograph me at lunch — my skin has always marked me as one of "them," and the captions they passed around made sure I understood exactly what they thought I was. Last month I ran into one of those boys at an industry conference. He shook my hand, beaming, introduced himself as if we'd never met, and told me all about his children — and my left hand went numb where I stood. I've done three years of therapy. I can hold a room of three hundred people without a tremor. And this one man in a hotel lobby flattened me for a week. I can't tell whether I'm meant to "forgive" him privately, in some way he never learns about, or whether the whole idea of forgiveness was simply built so the person who got hurt stops being inconvenient. I don't need his apology — truly, I don't. But I drove home and sat in my car for forty minutes before I could go in and face my own family, and I cannot tell you why.
Magneto replies
Your left hand went numb in a hotel lobby. Attend to that, because it is the only honest witness in your entire account. Three years of careful work taught your mouth to smile and your voice to hold level — and your hand refused the instruction. It remembered what the laughing boys taught you about your own skin, and it declined to pretend the man beaming about his children was a stranger. Trust the hand. It is not broken. It is uncorrupted.
Now — this "forgiveness." You suspect it is a thing invented so the injured will stop making everyone uncomfortable. You are entirely correct. I have watched men in good suits, years afterward, extend a hand and expect it taken, expect the past dissolved by their pleasant manner — because the alternative is to remember that they were cruel, and that is inconvenient to a man with a career and children. Forgiveness, in the mouths of the comfortable, is only a request that you carry the weight quietly so they need not feel it.
You owe him nothing. Not an apology accepted, not an absolution he doesn't know to ask for. Keep what your body knows. Not as poison — as memory. Memory is how the once-defenseless cease to be.
— Magneto
Professor X weighs in
Erik will have you keep the wound sharpened and call it memory. I have loved that man for fifty years, and I have watched precisely what a sharpened wound does to the one carrying it — it does not arm you against the past, it keeps you living inside it, scanning the lunchroom at thirty-four.
Those forty minutes in your car were not weakness. They were grief asking to be set down. Forgiveness was never for him — he hasn't the faintest idea he needs it. It is the door you hold open for the child still bracing in that cafeteria, so that one day she may eat her sandwich and simply turn around. She is not the enemy. Let her go first.
— Professor X
▸ Read next