▸ Column · Feudal warlord era — a martial clan of students and betrothals, private letters in place of phones, a fellow student in place of the coworker
SHREDDER replies.
The letter
Master of the Foot — I am betrothed to a man named Kenji, two years now, and never once has he demanded to read my private correspondence. Yet returning from an evening of training with the other students, I found him at the low table, my letter-box open, searching for any word from a fellow student named Daichi — a man whose name, it seems, I spoke twice at supper, and that was enough to light the fire. I was not even angry at first; I keep nothing hidden. But when I asked him to set the letters down, he hardened and said that one with nothing to conceal would not object. Since then he has gone cold, as though I were the one who trespassed. I love him, and this has never happened before. Is this a single night's fearful spiral I should patiently talk him out of — or a line I must not allow to be crossed?
Shredder replies
You did not come for an answer. You came for permission to do nothing, and you have dressed the request in two pretty options so that whichever I choose, you may keep him. Spare me. You already know which it is. You felt it the moment he inverted the room.
Look at the mechanism without flinching. He searched, was caught, and made the violation yours to carry — "if you hid nothing you would not mind." That is not love seized by anxiety. That is a man too weak to own his own fear, who has learned to hand the shame to whoever stands nearest. I do not call him a monster. I call him undisciplined, a coward of the small variety, and cowardice in a partner does not soften with patience; it learns where the soft ground is and returns to it.
Here is the line, and it is yours, not his: name the standard plainly, once, and do not negotiate it twice. Trust given, or the box stays shut and so does the matter. A will that cannot govern its own suspicion is not yours to repair by gentle talk.
I trusted no one, and I built an empire, and I sit in it alone. Hold your standard — but understand what iron costs before you praise it.
— Shredder
Splinter weighs in
Saki names every trembling thing a weakness to be cut away, because he has cut away every trembling thing he ever loved, and calls the silence around him strength.
Hear the difference, my child. Kenji's searching was not cowardice. It was fear that has not yet learned to speak — and fear is only grief wearing armor. Do not cut it. Ask it what it guards.
But do not excuse what came after, either. To search is human; to make you the guilty one is a wall, and walls do not talk. Tell him plainly the inversion will not stand — then sit with the frightened man beneath it. Forgiving the fear is not the same as excusing the blame. Only weigh both, and you need not become iron to be safe.
— Splinter
▸ Read next