▸ Column · The Walking Dead apocalypse — a walled settlement years into the dead, where Alpha answers as the matriarch of the Whisperers
ALPHA replies.
Replied to by Alpha, with a rebuttal from Rick Grimes.
The letter
I've been with Larry since the second winter — fourteen months, give or take, in a settlement where you learn fast who you can stand a watch beside. Last week he handed me a list. An actual list, scratched on a torn page: every place I keep things, every person I knew before the walls went up, the run logs, even who I trade with at the gate. He says people who've truly thrown in together keep nothing back, and that my flinching is itself the proof I'm holding out on him. To keep the peace I let him read the old letters I carried in from before. He went back years and grilled me about a man I knew long before I ever met him. Now he's stopped asking. He just leaves that list nailed by the door like a chore I haven't done. I love him. But I'm starting to feel like the suspect in my own home. Am I the unreasonable one, or is he?
Alpha replies
You felt something flinch in you when he handed you that list. That was not guilt, child. That was the animal under the person, smelling what it smells. You called it hesitation and went looking for a reason to apologize for it. Stop. The flinch was information. Obey the information.
Hear the costume he is wearing. "We hide nothing from each other" — he has dressed up a cage and called it closeness. A man who must wear your whole life to feel safe is not strong. He is frightened, and frightened things that cannot master their own fear reach out to own someone else's. That is weakness performing strength, and the wild keeps an honest ledger on such things.
The thing you are protecting is the word "love." It tells you the world inside your walls is gentle, that the man across the fire could not be the predator. So you leave the door open and call it trust. I will name it plainly, without malice: the love is the door. It does not mean you cut him loose tomorrow. It means you stop pretending the flinch lied. Keep what is yours. The one who needs none of it back is the only one you were ever safe beside.
— Alpha
Rick Grimes weighs in
No. The love's not the door, Alpha — the man is, and you'd call any door a liability rather than admit some are worth keeping open.
Look. I built a life with people I'd have died for, and the trust ran both ways without a leash on it. That's the tell here: Larry isn't asking you to throw in together. He's building a cage and nailing the work order to your door. A man who treats his own woman like a suspect is becoming somebody he oughta be scared of.
So don't strip your heart out to be safe. Keep the love. Lose the man who needs to own you to feel it. That's not the same thing, no matter what she tells you.
— Rick Grimes
▸ Read next