▸ Column · Modern gothic-noir Gotham — Catwoman reading letters between heists
CATWOMAN replies.
The letter
My girlfriend Priya and I took a place together in Gotham eight months back — a $2,800 apartment, split straight down the middle, fair and square when we were both pulling the same kind of paycheck. Then I landed a promotion that nearly doubled mine, and she jumped to a nonprofit she adores that pays around $38k. Now I watch her skip the market stalls, beg off weekend trips, quietly going without — while my savings just sit there fattening up. Every time I float a proportional split, something like 65/35, she goes cold and says she won't be my "charity case." I don't see her that way at all. I don't want to trample her pride, but I hate that this arrangement is shrinking her world while mine widens. Is there a way to fix the math that doesn't make her feel like a kept woman — or are we just wired too differently about money to last?
Catwoman replies
Here's what you've got wrong, sugar: you think this is a math problem. It isn't. Priya's not protecting her pride — she's protecting her exit. The second you cover her half of that rent, you're holding the key to the cage she lives in. She knows it even if you don't. That's not charity she's scared of. It's dependence. It's waking up in a room she can't walk out of without your permission.
So stop trying to pay her rent. Leave her name on her own half — that's hers, that's her claw out, and it's worth more than any spreadsheet. What you do instead is fund the joy. You take the trips. You fill the market basket. You make the extras yours, freely, no ledger, no terms. The roof over her head stays her own; the wider life is the gift.
That way she keeps the one thing that actually matters — the ability to leave — and you stop watching her shrink. Incompatible? Please. You're just both trying to be generous in a language that reads as control. Cut a different key. The trick, handsome, is choosing where you land.
— Catwoman
Batman weighs in
Of course she tells you to leave an escape route. Selina always packs a getaway car before she's through the door. That's not love. That's a thief casing a relationship for the exits.
You moved in together. That means you stop keeping separate ledgers and start building a shared one. Pool it. Total transparency. An emergency fund neither of you touches alone. Priya's pride isn't a cage to respect — it's a fault line. Untreated, it cracks under the first real pressure.
Don't fund her joy from across a moat, Selina. Stand on the same ground. Commit. Or admit you never meant to.
— Batman
▸ Read next