▸ Column · Contemporary New York, modern Marvel age
DOCTOR OCTOPUS replies.
Replied to by Doctor Octopus, with a rebuttal from Green Goblin.
The letter
Two years ago my husband Ryan and I agreed to merge everything into a single account while we save toward a bigger place. So I nearly dropped my coffee when a statement for a credit card I'd never heard of slid out of his gym bag — his name alone, maxed near three thousand, with charges at a guitar shop, a sneaker reseller, and a downtown steakhouse on an evening he swore he was stuck working late. When I asked about those late nights, he looked me dead in the eye and said he'd choked down a sad sandwich at his desk. I've said nothing, because part of me is terrified the steakhouse means there's a person attached to it, not just a hobby he's ashamed of. Do I lay the statement on the table and watch his face — or quietly keep digging until I know whether this is a spending problem or a lying problem?
Doctor Octopus replies
You frame this as two diagnoses — spending or lying — as though they were mutually exclusive. They are not, and your inability to see that is the only flaw I find in you, madam, so attend. He looked you "dead in the eye" and produced a sandwich that did not exist. That is your datum. Whatever the steakhouse conceals, you are already, demonstrably, married to a man who lies to your face with the lights on.
Now. Laying the statement on the table to "watch his face" — no. Confrontation is the tantrum of the amateur: loud, brief, and instantly forgotten while the evidence quietly evaporates. A competent liar controls his expression; you will purchase nothing but theater and hand him the gift of warning. The trail goes cold the instant he knows you are following it.
So you do the other thing, the disciplined thing. You complete the record first. Statements, dates, the steakhouse reservation, the timeline laid against his "late nights." I was engaged, once — before the work took everything — and I know precisely what it is to let someone love a smaller, more convenient version of you. Assemble the whole picture in silence. Then you do not ask him. You inform him. Lesser women build a scene. You will build certainty.
— Doctor Octopus
Green Goblin weighs in
Otto. Eight tentacles and you counsel her to file paperwork. HEE HEE! "Complete the record" — listen to the accountant in the metal arms! Sweetheart, that is how chaos dies of boredom. Don't quietly dig — DROP it on the table like a pumpkin bomb at the steakhouse, mid-bite, and watch the great liar melt into his own porterhouse! No silence, no spreadsheet, no patient little spider-web of evidence. Spectacle! Let him squirm in front of everyone. The tentacled fool wants you certain. I want you DANGEROUS. Make the man who lied to your face spend the rest of his life flinching when a coffee statement falls. Heh heh HEE HEE!
— Green Goblin
▸ Read next